Otterbein University Athletics

All-American Honors:

Name	Year	Award
Jennifer Harrison	2001-02	Honorable Mention
Diana Esterkamp	2003-04	Honorable Mention
Dani Kissel	2018-19	Honorable Mention

All-OAC 1st Team:

Name	Year
Lori Povisil	1985-86
Lori Povisil	1986-87
Amy Bates	1989-90
Becky Kok	1991-92
Jenny Lambert	1995-96
Jen Burns	1998-99
Jennifer Harrison (OAC Player of the Year)	2001-02
Diana Esterkamp	2002-03
Diana Esterkamp	2003-04
Danielle Holbrook	2004-05
Danielle Holbrook	2005-06
Laura Roth	2006-07
Laura Roth	2007-08
Laura Roth	2008-09
Kristi Kotterman	2011-12
Shea McCoy	2011-12
Hannah Day	2012-13
Amariah Huck	2015-16
Kiersten Taylor	2017-18
Dani Kissel	2018-19
Katie McCrary	2021-22

All-OAC 2nd Team:

Name	Year
Amy Bates	1987-88
Angie Spencer	1987-88
Amy Bates	1988-89
Angie Spencer	1988-89
Becky Kok	1990-91
Jenny Lambert	1994-95
Jenny Lambert	1996-97
Kara Grishkat	1999-00
Diana Esterkamp	2001-02
Brianne Gray	2002-03
Heather Gepper	2003-04
Abby Perez	2004-05
Sara Esterkamp	2006-07
Sara Fee	2007-08
Katy Miller	2009-10
Kristi Kotterman	2010-11
Shea McCoy	2010-11
Tabatha Piper	2012-13
Tabatha Piper	2013-14
Dani Kissel	2015-16
Kiersten Taylor	2016-17
Dani Kissel	2016-17
Dani Kissel	2017-18
Ali Cartnal	2018-19
Abbie Scholz	2019-20
Katie McCrary (OAC Freshman of the Year)	2020-21
Angelia Jackson	2020-21
Katie McCrary	2022-23

All-OAC Honorable Mention:

Name	Year
Rhonda Scarf	1986-87
Donna Peters	1987-88
Becky Kok	1989-90
Elaine Gonya	1990-91
Elaine Gonya	1991-92
Terri Hogg	1993-94
Jenny Lambert	1993-94
Jen Burns	1996-97
Jen Burns	1997-98
Julie Good	1997-98
Kara Grishkat	1998-99
Sarah Kuhner	1998-99
Lisa Patton	1998-99
Sarah Kuhner	1999-00
Brianne Gray	2000-01
Kara Grishkat	2000-01
Jennifer Harrison	2000-01
Gretchen Linscott	2000-01
Jill Repass	2001-02
Brianne Gray	2003-04
Sara Fee	2005-06
Abbey Perez	2005-06
Laura Roth	2005-06
Sara Fee	2006-07
Ana Gamble	2006-07
Katy Miller	2006-07
Katy Miller	2008-09
Kristi Kotterman	2009-10
Shea McCoy	2009-10
Hannah Day	2011-12
Chelsea Reed	2014-15
Amariah Huck	2014-15
Ali Cartnal	2017-18
Delaney Cutteridge	2019-20
Jenna Hoschouer	2020-21
Angelia Jackson	2021-22
Kathleen DeCarlo	2022-23
Jenna Hoschouer	2022-23
Maizie King	2023-24

Academic All-OAC Honors: 

Name	Year
Becy Kok (1st Team)	1990-91
Elaine Gonya (Honorable Mention)	1990-91
Sharon Hathaway (Honorable Mention)	1990-91
Elaine Gonya (1st Team)	1991-92
Becky Kok (1st Team)	1991-92
Julie Orr (Honorable Mention)	1991-92
Terri Hogg (2nd Team)	1992-93
Terri Hogg (1st Team)	1993-94
Ali Davis (Honorable Mention)	1994-95
Ali Davis (1st Team)	1995-96
Jenny Lambert (Honorable Mention)	1995-96
Ali Davis (1st team)	1996-97
Jennifer Lambert (Honorable Mention)	1996-97
Julie Good (Honorable Mention)	1996-97
Jamie Steffen (1st Team)	1997-98
Renae Bexfield (Honorable Mention)	1997-98
Julie Good (Honorable Mention)	1997-98
Jen Burns (1st Team)	1998-99
Angie Wilson (Honorable Mention)	1998-99
Kara Grishkat (1st Team)	1999-00
Sarah Kuhner (Honorable Mention)	1999-00
Kara Grishkat (1st Team)	2000-01
Gretchen Linscott (Honorable Mention)	2000-01
Jill Repass (1st Team)	2001-02
Katy Witt (Honorable Mention)	2003-04
Danielle Holbrook (1st Team)	2004-05
Abbey Perez (1st Team)	2004-05
Valerie Ruschau (Honorable Mention)	2004-05
Danielle Holbrook (1st Team)	2005-06
Abbey Perez (1st Team)	2005-06
Sara Fee (Honorable Mention)	2005-06
Sara Fee (1st Team)	2006-07
Sara Fee (1st Team)	2007-08
Laura Roth (1st Team)	2007-08
Laura Roth (1st Team)	2008-09
Karli Volkmer (Honorable Mention)	2008-09
Karli Volkmer (Honorable Mention)	2009-10*
Katie Stallard (Honorable Mention)	2009-10*
Alayna Barnes	2012-13
Laura Gilmore	2012-13
Chelsea Reed	2012-13
Chelsea Reed	2013-14
Gracie Staten	2013-14
Lindsey Rosendale	2013-14
Chelsea Reed	2014-15
Lindsey Rosendale	2014-15
Cheyenne Hartley-Carr	2014-15
Taylor Pifher	2015-16
Kiersten Taylor	2015-16
Taylor Pifher	2016-17
Jacy Jones	2016-17
Delaney Cutteridge	2017-18
Alex Schaffer	2017-18
Jacy Jones	2017-18
Abby Miduri	2017-18
Alex Schaffer	2018-19
Jacy Jones	2018-19
Delaney Cutteridge	2018-19
Bryn Mangold	2018-19
Hailey Bauer	2019-20
Delaney Cutteridge	2019-20
Jenna Hoschouer	2019-20
Bryn Mangold	2019-20
Jenna Hoschouer	2020-21
Bryn Mangold	2020-21
Natalie Galaida	2021-22
Danielle Horsley	2021-22
Jenna Hoschouer	2021-22
Olivia Majors	2021-22
Hailey Dennis	2022-23
Natalie Galaida	2022-23
Jenna Hoschouer	2022-23
Olivia Majors	2022-23

* = OAC stopped giving 1st Team, 2nd Team, and Honorable Mention after the 2009-10 season