Mike Grayem (2026) - Hall of Fame - Otterbein University Athletics

Otterbein University Athletics

Hall of Fame

Mike Grayem

Class

1966
Induction

2026
Sport(s)

Men's Basketball

Few individuals have embodied Otterbein's spirit of lifelong service and loyalty more completely than Mike Grayem. A standout member of one of the most successful eras in Cardinal basketball history, Grayem's impact extended far beyond his playing days, as he spent decades shaping the lives of young people throughout central Ohio while proudly representing his alma mater.

A native of Reynoldsburg, Ohio, Grayem arrived at Otterbein in 1962 and immediately made his mark on the hardwood. As a freshman, he led the Cardinals in scoring while playing alongside future Otterbein legends. His offensive ability was evident throughout his career, highlighted by a 24-point performance against Central State and an 18-point outing against Muskingum that included the game-winning basket.

Grayem's development and work ethic earned him the team's Most Improved Player Award during the 1964-65 season. Later that year, he played a pivotal role in one of the most memorable trips in program history when Otterbein traveled to New York and captured the Hofstra Classic championship. Grayem delivered outstanding performances throughout the tournament, scoring 22 points against Hofstra, 25 against New Hampshire, and 28 against Adelphi en route to First Team All-Classic honors.

During Grayem's final three seasons, Otterbein compiled records of 16-5, 16-9, and 20-5, establishing what was then the winningest stretch in program history. Under legendary coach Curt Tong, the Cardinals claimed Ohio Athletic Conference Southern Division championships in 1964, 1965, and 1966 while also becoming the first Otterbein team to defeat Akron.

Following graduation in 1966, Grayem devoted his life to education and coaching. He served as an English teacher and basketball coach at Hamilton Township, Westerville South, and Reynoldsburg High Schools, where he became a respected mentor to generations of students and athletes. His passion was never solely about wins and losses. Rather, it was about helping young people become better individuals through discipline, character, and hard work. His contributions to athletics and education earned him induction into the Reynoldsburg High School Hall of Fame.

Throughout his coaching career, Grayem remained "Loyal and True" to Otterbein, encouraging countless students to attend his alma mater and helping strengthen the connection between Reynoldsburg and the University until his passing in 2017.

Explore HOF Explore Hall of Fame Members